What time of the year Mel. How many ADR's would you do.
We will probably go for Halloween - incorporating the October school holidays into our trip. We will hopefully be gone around six weeks so there willbe a bit of flexibility in the dates we are at WDW. As for ADRs - one a day, or two every three days seems about right. We will do quite a few character meals so that we don't have to stand in line to meet them.
I would suggest maybe the annual pass for at least one person so you then qualify for the 10% discount on goods, this covers even water, chocolates or even ask if not sure. The important thing you can get is the Tables in Wonderland card which will give you 20% discount on any ADR, you would need to check if there are any block out dates, eg Christmas day NYE for is not included for us in the TIW, TIW gets your money back after 5 meals I think. You only need one TIW for a group of ten I think as long as the TIW person is paying. To get the AP or TIW discounts you will sometimes be asked for photo ID.
The PAP gets you 20% discount on merchandise and you really need to do the sums to see if it is worthwhile. We looked at buying a reproduction painting and having it shipped home, at $2,000.00 value the extra cost for the PAP it would be worth it.
Keep in mind a 10 day pass with park hopper option does not have to be used on consecutive days, so might suit the 14 days at WDW. I think it is cheaper to go AP than add an extra day to the 10 day. We are in a different situation as we get a DVC discount and another discount for the renewal.
Character meals we do Crystal Palace, Cape May Cafe for breakfast, Tuskerhouse. Depending on where you stay the best value meal for breakfast is Captains Grille in the Yacht Club, couldnt ask for better international buffet and costs us $35.00 US with the TIW for two of us.